The Second Season of Nashville Star aired its second show, Saturday, March 13, 2004
This time the 5 for America to vote as the 11th Contestant would be announced. They were called out to join the stage by Nancy O'Dell(The Official Nashville Star Hostess)
- Anessa Andrews
- Brad Cotter
- Rachel Williams
- Laura Sullivan
- Austin Hanks
The 11th Contestant Brad Cotter
First to perform
Just after being announced as the 11th Contestant was
Brad Cotter, he sang "Who Would'nt Want To Be Me" Keith Urban
To Vote by Phone dial: 1 866 978 2701
Judges comments:
- Tracy -Professional, Composed, Top Job
- Greenwood - For you to just be coming out here being announced as the 11th Contestant - Great Job
- Warren Bros - Modern Day Pat Boone - jokingly
Jennifer Hicks "He's My Kind Of Rain" Tim McGraw,
Originaly "She's My Kind Of Rain".. Jennifer changed it in honor of her 16 month old son, because it reminded her of him.
To Vote by Phone dial: 1 866 978 2702
Judges comments :
- Tracy -Endearing Quality and Sound
- Warren Bros. - Did not know how she could pull off singing a Tim McGraw song, but she did it
- Greenwood -She did it. (Awful hard to follow this Judge at times)
Mal Rodgers - "Gone Country" Alan Jackson
To Vote by Phone dial: 1 866 978 2703
* Mal is an Ireland native and came out wearing a black hat this time*
Judges comments:
- Tracy - Tough Night- Maybe not the right song choice
- Greenwood - Stay True to yourself; Be who you are. Judge did say that often when one arrives in Nashville they think they need to change but offered advise for him to ' Be himself ; be Mal Rodgers from Ireland".
- Warren Bros- Last week the mohawk / mullet this week the Black Hat.... but still Good job.
- Tracy added He did have Energy.


